THE AVENUE TO SUCCESS
Cousins Properties utilizes the past to gauge future success.
Dawn Pick Benson
One
of the foremost diversified real estate development companies
in the United States, Atlanta-based Cousins Properties, is
more concerned about quality than quantity, according to Joel
Murphy, president of Cousins Properties retail division. "Our
goal is not to become bigger in size for the sake of size,
our goal is to create more value for our current shareholders,"
he says. "Instead of going out and buying a $100 million
office building or retail project, our preference is to invest
$100 million of equity in development projects and create
$140 million of value."
Founded in 1958 by Thomas G. Cousins, chairman of the board and chief
executive officer, Cousins Properties currently focuses on the development
of commercial retail and office properties in selected markets throughout
the country. The company went public in 1960, qualified as a real estate
investment trust (REIT) in 1987 and is publicly traded on the New York
Stock Exchange under the symbol CUZ.
Since the company' founding, it has developed more than 20 million square
feet of office space and over 12 million square feet of retail space,
including seven regional malls. In addition, the company has developed
more than 3,000 multifamily units and at least 30 single-family subdivisions.
Cousins Properties actively develops in many Southeast markets, including
North Carolina, Virginia, Florida and Georgia, and has full-service offices
in Atlanta and Charlotte. It also has developments in Texas and California.
According to Murphy, Cousins Properties is unique in comparison to other
publicly traded real estate companies in that the company primarily develops
or redevelops projects for its own account rather than acquires properties
developed by others. "A lot of other companies, while they may do some
development, are primarily in the acquisition business," he says.
Cousin' second distinguishing factor is that it is diversified by product
type. "We develop and own office and retail, and we also have a land division
that deals with single-family residential, which has been a significant
part of the company since the early 1960s." Murphy notes that Cousins
Properties has its roots as a single-family residential developer.
A New Development Concept
In recent years, Cousins Properties has expanded its success in the retail
market through its new development concept, The Avenue. Introduced in
1998, this concept came from conversations between Murphy and several
specialty retailers about putting together a project in an open air, non-regional
mall environment. These retailers felt that a development like this could
bring them closer to customers that they believed weren1t being reached
by traditional malls. Intrigued by the idea, Cousins Properties did a
detailed demographic scan of the Atlanta market based on income and growth
and a variety of other factors. "We decided if we were going to do one
of these, we wanted to do it in our own backyard," says Murphy. "We had
no idea going into it that our own backyard would be seven miles from
our corporate headquarters. That' where we developed The Avenue East
Cobb."
The Avenue East Cobb in Atlanta is an upscale, open-air, well-landscaped,
pedestrian-friendly shopping center with traditional mall-based retailers
such as Gap, Banana Republic, Ann Taylor, Talbots, Williams Sonoma and
Pottery Barn. It appeals to the time-constrained shopper who wants high-quality
merchandise in a more convenient setting than a regional mall provides.
Through the success of this 225,000-square-foot center, which is now 100
percent leased and occupied with reportedly outstanding sales, Cousins
Properties has opened The Avenue of the Peninsula in Los Angeles and The
Avenue Peachtree City in southern metropolitan Atlanta. The company is
also in the pre-development stage of The Avenue Chenal in Little Rock,
Arkansas, and in other markets as well. "We' taking all the best components
of things we1ve learned and are now working to roll out the concept in
a little more of a broad basis, all under the name, ¯The Avenue,1" says
Murphy. "The bottom line is that all the projects will have basic similarities,
yet each will be tailored to the particular market in which it' located.
Our goal is for our retailers to know that if it' an Avenue, it will
have a consistently high standard for excellence."
And so far, this concept is well-received by retail customers. For example,
The Avenue Peachtree City opened its doors on March 29 and early results
from retail sales in the first weeks were nothing short of extraordinary.
"Virtually all of the retailers are exceeding their plan by a significant
percentage and are quite stunned at the breadth of the trade area and
the distance people are driving to come to the center," says Murphy. "When
you house all these specialty stores in one place, customers--in the Peachtree
City case--don1t have to make the 45 minute drive one way to a quality
mall. We are providing a very appealing shopping alternative, especially
in an area like Fayette County, which is very affluent with high growth,
and in our opinion, under served for quality retail." The 175,000-square-foot
center celebrated its grand opening with a "community celebration" on
May 5.
As a result of The Avenue concept' success, Cousins Properties is considering
other markets in the Southeast and the Southwest in which to develop.
"I think the challenge for this type of development is understanding your
market and understanding that these projects have to be set on real estate
with certain unique characteristics," says Murphy. He says he is now being
approached by others with ideas for key sites or a particular market for
an Avenue project. Murphy finds this idea appealing: "It allows us to
grow more rapidly The Avenue concept as opposed to doing 100 percent of
every deal ourselves. We can put our expertise in this product type together
with our national merchant relationships and strong capital position.
I think this makes us an attractive partner." Murphy also notes that this
same strategy can be applied to neighborhood and power center products
as well.
In addition to The Avenue Peachtree City, Cousins Properties is also
working on a specialty mixed-use development called The Arboretum that
will include office, retail, residential and hotel components in Cary,
North Carolina. The project will be anchored by Renaissance Hotel by Marriott,
a 186-room, four-star hotel developed by Summit Hospitality of Raleigh,
North Carolina. "This will be the first four-star hotel in the Research
Triangle," says Murphy. The Arboretum is in the pre-development phase
and the company plans on breaking ground this fall. It is slated for completion
in the fall of 2002. "We like the Research Triangle market," says Murphy,
"because it is stable, has good growth, a high quality of life, and it'
a great place to live and work."
Looking to the Future
When asked about the future of retail in the Southeast, Murphy says that
demand for space in Cousin' projects is quite good. "I do think that
some retailers are being more cautious than they were previously because
many of their store' comp sales have been flat or in some cases, negative,"
he says. "I think that has caused retailers to be a bit more cautious
in future store capital allocations as well as a little more conservative
in sales and sales growth projections." But Murphy has also found that
in a well-conceived project, people are still opening new locations and
are still bullish about the future prospects of their stores. "If it'
a well-conceived project, they are willing to step up and do what it takes
to make a deal." He also notes that it' difficult to make a global statement
about the retail market in general, but points out that Cousins Propertie'
retail projects are 97 percent occupied. "By definition, that means demand
is pretty good, but we are still keeping a close eye on it."
An institutionally favored product type right now is the neighborhood
anchored shopping centers. "We develop these centers and will continue
to because they are attractive to the investment community," says Murphy.
Unlike the grocery-anchored centers, the demand in the investment community
for power centers has weakened. In fact, Cousins Properties has trimmed
its portfolio in the power center business over the last 4 to 5 years,
harvesting the value created and investing the capital in new retail and
office projects. "We are still bullish on power centers as a product type
as long as we control the best piece of real estate in the particular
submarket and only do tenant deals with retailers first or second in their
category."
Another investment vehicle that the company likes is, of course, The
Avenue. "This is a vehicle that we feel can establish a fair return for
our shareholders," says Murphy, "and at the same time, it offers an extremely
attractive return to our retailer partners because their occupancy costs
in an Avenue are often 40 percent less than in a traditional regional
mall." He also adds that an Avenue is not burdened by the CAM and overhead
charges of many enclosed malls.
Murphy also believes that opportunities for development will continue
in the Southeast, but he is tightening up the front-end underwriting.
"When you combine the favorable weather and the employment opportunities
in the Southeast, it' extraordinary," says Murphy. "It' no accident
that the Southeast and the Southwest continue to see employment and population
growth." Where the people are is where there will be the best opportunities
for well-conceived development. That' why the company is focused on the
Southeast, the Southwest and other sunbelt markets, he adds.
With prosperity, there is also the fear of overbuilding. While certain
submarkets might get overbuilt for office and retail on a temporary basis,
Murphy doesn1t think the Southeast will see the "almost irresponsible"
speculative building that occurred in the 1980s with the "old ¯build it
and they will come1 motto." He sites Atlanta, which, on a per square foot
basis, has an amount of retail per capita that exceeds the national norm.
At the same time, he points out, its growth is so extraordinary that there
continues to be retail demand. "Statistically, Atlanta is overbuilt,"
he says. "But in retail, you have to look a lot closer at submarkets and
the particular project cotenancies in the submarkets. I think there are
still retail opportunities in Atlanta, they' just more niche-based opportunities
as opposed to major regional-based centers."
So what does the future hold for Cousins Properties? "The best way to
look at where we are headed is to look back at where we1ve been," says
Muphy. Since 1977, the company has posted an average annual return of
24.9 percent to its shareholders. If one looks at investments over the
last 25 years, that number is consistent with returns delivered by blue
chips such as Time Warner, GE, Coca Cola and Bank of America. "Realizing
that we1ve made returns equal to or better than a lot of those companies
over a 25 year horizon tells us that we are a company that not only knows
how to grow and deliver superior returns to our shareholders during the
good times, but we1ve also shown how to operate successfully during the
downturns of 1980 to 1981 and 1990 to 1991." Murphy notes that the company
has been through these difficult times and in fact, feels it can be even
stronger in a relative period of economic malaise. "Because we have such
a low level of debt within our company, we can take advantage of opportunities
that others might not be able to take advantage of in a downturn," Murphy
says. "So I think looking at our past is a good way to gauge where we
see our future."
©2001 France Publications, Inc. Duplication
or reproduction of this article not permitted without authorization
from France Publications, Inc. For information on reprints of
this article contact Barbara
Sherer at (630) 554-6054.
|